Categories

25 years since bhopal tragedy

My heartfelt sympathies for all the victims – dead and alive.

The night of Dec 3rd 1984 changed the fate of nearly 500,000 people and the face of Bhopal industrial scenario. They are still hoping and waiting for things to get better. Hazardous gas Methyl Isocyanate (MIC) leaked from the pesticide plant of Union Carbide Company (UCC) killing thousands and leaving tens of thousands handicapped. That tragedy still haunts the people of Bhopal as the leak has contaminated the ground water. The chemical has made the water toxic for drinking to date and as a result there are a high percentage of children born with birth defects that stay with them for the rest of their lives.

Reasons for the accident are controversial to date, the stories of the workers of the plant and the management vary about what happened in the plant that night. Safety regulations were clearly violated. The location of the plant near densely populated area and lack of any disaster management in place made the situation worse. Lack of knowledge about the poisonous gas and the ways to deal with the exposure made it impossible for the government of India and Madhya Pradesh to deal with a disaster that affected so many lives. And the way the government chose to
investigate the incident raises many questions as they was very discreet about the information released and nothing was ever clearly disclosed about the findings of the investigation until the year 2003. Though the company involved UCC has accepted to pay the penalty for civil and criminal responsibility in the form of 470 million dollars as compensation to the victims, to date it has not disclosed the chemical composition of MIC, making it difficult to find a permanent solution to treat the drinking water.

It has been 25 years since the fatal accident and still everyday there is a new victim waiting for help thanks to the toxic water, but hope is still alive that someday this case file will be closed completely and justifiably. Every time there is a large scale tragedy be it Bhopal gas leak or any other natural disaster or terrorist attack of 26/11 in India, we fail time and again to respond in an effective way due to the lack of proper disaster management systems in place which could save many lives lost in vain. No proper measures seem to have ever been taken by authorities to implement a proper response system and conveniently this issue is forgotten once news
channels and newspapers stop reporting about the incident. Bhopal gas leak is a classic case to understand what happens in the absence of effective response system, proper implementation of safety regulations could have prevented this situation but we cannot stop natural disasters to happen though with proper planning we can save the lives of hundreds that would be affected. I think one way to give justice to the victims is to address the issue of proper disaster responsive system. It should be in place before something happens so that we will be well equipped to deal with the difficult situations and natural disasters.

Global Warming - Myth or Reality

Global warming – is it a myth or reality. Sometimes I wonder if the human caused global warming is a myth created by the developed countries. When you look at the history of the earth for the last few thousand years, it has gone through dramatic climate changes from extreme heat to extreme cold without human interference.

The developed countries have polluted the earth for the last 200 years to build their infrastructure and economies. Now as the developing countries are competing against them and slowly rising as economic powers, they could have created this myth to keep the developing countries from crossing them in economic might. I am not saying that India should pollute as it rises economically, but at the same time it should not be forced to pay for the mistakes made by the west. One might argue that all the scientists are saying we are causing global warming, then you can argue that a few centuries back all the scientists of that era believed the earth was flat. Everybody believes in something until the next invention or discovery is made to disprove it, then the next cycle begins.

There is another example of how these countries would use double standards. During the 80′s and 90′s as India was fighting Pakistan sponsored terrorism in Punjab and Kashmir, the Indian police and armed forces were criticized for human rights violations. After 9/11 and the same terrorists attacked USA, people were arrested without any charges, tortured, humiliated and killed. There is no one talking about human rights anymore. In the 90′s it was human rights, now its global warming and next they might use some other ploy. But at the same time we should try to avoid polluting the earth whether it is a cause for global warming or not.

We may cause the demise of some species and the growth of others. And in the end even if we cause our own extinction, life on earth will go on. The time of the humans on earth for the last few thousand years is insignificant when compared to the age of the earth and the changes it has gone through.